I'm not sure that they actually ban it. You just have to go through their approval processes first! In fact, they are currently ordering the current Dalai Lama to reincarnate while he threatens not to. They really want to handpick and manipulate the next one. When the last Panchen Lama was named as a child, he disappeared. And then the government named their own! Of course, Tibetans generally reject the Chinese version. It is really ironic to see the Dalai Lama--who believes in reincarnation--trying to control and resist the possibility and the Communist--who don't believe in it--demanding that it happen. The "compromise" will probably be naming someone outside of China as the successor. India, Nepal, and Bhutan all have significant Tibetan Buddhist populations.
Tibetan Buddhist here! (That is, I practice Tibetan Buddhism; I’m not actually Tibetan. Think Richard Gere, but cooler.) Basically, high incarnate lamas such as the Dalai Lama and the Karmapa have a great deal of political clout and power (the Dalai Lama had been – for many centuries – the temporal head of the Tibetan people as well as the spiritual, until the current one stepped down as political leader and told his people to get over it and embrace democracy, for crying out loud). All of these high lamas have escaped China over the decades, usually with dramatic nighttime exoduses, traveling through the Himalayas to get to India.
Now free of China, these lamas can say anything they want, like how China slaughtered most of them and burned down hundreds of monasteries, et al. In order to prevent this, the Chinese want to ensure that any new recognized incarnations are in their country, under their control (like their fake Panchen Lama), and not stir up any Tibetan uprisings.
(con’t.) So actually, AkJMB actually has it backwards: the Chinese are only going to “approve” rebirths (we like that word better than “reincarnation”) born in China.
From Wikipedia:
On August 3, 2007, China's State Administration for Religious Affairs issued a decree that all the reincarnations of tulkus of Tibetan Buddhism must get government approval, otherwise they are "illegal or invalid". The decree states, "It is an important move to institutionalize management on reincarnation of living Buddhas. The selection of reincarnates must preserve national unity and solidarity of all ethnic groups and the selection process cannot be influenced by any group or individual from outside the country."
(Last one!) Tibetan Buddhism is actually souring on the whole reincarnate lama (aka “tulku”) system as a whole. (Buddhism in general is fairly flexible like that.) It’s had some serious problems, both historically as well as today. HHDL has been pretty bearish on his own personal future rebirth, saying that even if he did, it would NOT be under Chinese rule (and yes, there are Western tulkus). Plus he’s been preparing people for the possibility of his rebirth being a woman! There are definitely high women tulkus (including one of my teachers, Her Eminence Khandro Rinpoche), just not that high.
Other Buddhist traditions (Zen, Theravada, Pure Land, etc.) rely only on accomplishment and worthiness to elevate people to revered teacher. The Tibetans were utterly isolated until 1949, but now, seeing that system, are coming to realize that it’s a much, much better idea.
Interesting, actually read the whole thing and usually I dont like big blocks of text. But usually they are more political or minute historic details, and often written with ego and attitude and about them being right.
just informative texts without ego motivation are a much lighter read. I have learned a lot :)
Yea the worst movie ever made.. (sarcasm). I seriously don't get why people call things awful when they are not in their personal top 10. Things that are not perfect or fitting their desire are immediately awful.., makes me wonder how they treat people and their general approach to life.
out of the millions movies made, for something to be awful they really must be terribly unimaginably bad. A movie isnt awful because you find it boring or dont like the plot etc
I wouldn't call Avatar awful. Is it James Cameron's best? No, I don't think so. Is it his worst? Also unlikely. Piranha II exists, after all. Overrated? Yeah, probably. I was more impressed by the special effects in T2 than in Avatar. But I wouldn't go so far as to call it awful.
Why are there so many people who are so proud of announcing that they haven't seen or don't like this movie? Is it just because it was the most popular highest-grossing movie of all time? Reminds me of those people wearing "Trendy people suck" t-shirts back in the 90s... irony being that those shirts were extremely trendy.
Depictions of skeletons are also apparently forbidden. Magic: the Gathering cards featuring them that are reprinted for sale in China must have the artwork redone so that there is some flesh still on the skeletal form.
I thought the Canadian singer would be K.D. Lang simply for being a lesbian. The thought of banning Bieber, just seems to give to much importance to someone who is essentially a joke.
Good concept! If I was to add some it would be video game consoles since they were banned from 2000 to 2015. As for specific games I recall Hearts of Iron being banned for depicting Taiwan and Japanese satellite state as being independent.
Man what a stupid country. I hate when some kind of a dictator or a government etc. comes on top of you and decides what you can and can not do. Take away their power to enforce and all you get is an empty disgusting egoistic shell.
I have a question. Why did they ban Justin Bieber? Is it because he "behaves badly", or is it because he has a lack of ability, which he most definitely does?
The Beijing culture bureau released a statement lauding Bieber's singing and musical "talent," but said that he was banned due to unspecified "bad behavior." They also said that they hoped he would mature with age so that he could be enjoyed by a wider audience.
Though it's not known for sure what behavior of Justin's put him on the bureau's radar, it has been speculated that it might have to do with him posting a selfie from a Japanese shrine that celebrates war criminals who participated in the rape of Nanjing and other atrocities in China and Korea.
Come on I as a Chinese can assure you people's got quite a lot of freedom as long as they've got enough money, government don't take much from the rich nowadays
They are allowed to have cryptocurrency they already have. And pirated edition of those films and books are available. Also "Winnie" is a banned word, but "Pooh-Pooh Bear" is allowed.
About 95% of the female profiles on Facebook's in-app dating feature now are fake Chinese scammer accounts of people trying to trick lonely/stupid men into buying some BS cryptocurrency.
Also Avatar is not banned in 3D which is kind of weird. The reason of that is cuz the CCP thinks that people wouldn't focus on the central theme being too fascinated by the effects.
It works out fine because most people are probably going to get it anyways after a moment's trial and error, but you might want to accept "babies" for "children."
Incredibly surprisingly, Animal Farm (and also 1984) actually isn't banned here. I've heard explanations ranging from "both books are about Britain, which means that Britain is a dystopian hellhole", and "animal farm is just a book about a farm", which are... interesting arguments. The Chinese version of 1984 apparently removed all references to Mao though. Also, I have no idea what you mean by jasmine being banned. Jasmine tea is pretty popular here. Unless there's a specific type of jasmine that has been banned here for some reason that I don't know about, I don't think that one is true either. Everything else checks out this time though, as far as I'm aware.
For those too lazy to search, there were pro-democracy protests in 2011 that some people were calling the "Jasmine revolution". Thus the ban. Which I guess was temporary.
Perhaps the clue should specify "jasmine flower" (given the extreme popularity and historical significance of other jasmine products like teas) to avoid unnecessary confusion. A clearer indication that some of these bans were temporary or have since been lifted could also be a good idea (it is stated clearly for some clues but not others, and worded vaguely in the description).
Most? Tell me which ones aren't banned. Jasmine flowers and Animal Farm are the only ones I'm aware of. And don't bother talking to Chinese people about this, because they might not even be aware (or care) that most of these things are banned. China is an extremely apathetic country when it comes to things getting banned. Source: I've lived here since 2013.
Not banned, is it? Just not approved by the culture bureau for release in Chinese theaters last I checked. Which isn't at all uncommon, as they only approve a limited number of Western films for release each year.
Gotta give them a pass for the Canadien singer. I'm curious on the jasmine and Back to the Future answers, but I'm sure they are somewhere in the comments.
Jetpunk is NOT banned in China as of December 2022, as I'm writing this comment in my home in Beijing, China :)
A few notes:
1. Though the reference to the Tian'anmen Square Massacre is strictly banned, the mentioning of the square itself is not —the founding of PRC is proclaimed by Mao on Tian'anmen Gate in 1949, and the once-a-decade military parades are still held at the square (last edition was in 2019)
We Chinese are more used to refer to the incident by its DATE (June 4th) instead of its location, as many other events with substantial historical significance also took place at the Square.
The one child policy was not a ban (neither was it really enforced, which is why when you meet many PRC nationals, they do have siblings), you paid for the second kid's education, healthcare etc, and a fine for a third.
Also jasmine isn;t banned, you could put it as 'cut flower jasmine from Beijing wholesale markets in 2011', I dunno.
There was No Banned in China for Avatar(a 2009 film directed by Cameron). It was the highest-grossing film in China at the time. According to Wikipedia, it is still the 36th highest-grossing film in China now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avatar_(2009_film)
I strongly suspect that the view thought Avatar has been banned in China confused the film with the animation Avatar: The Last Airbender, whose sometimes simplified as Avatar. Despite no clear evidence indicating the animation has been banned, its subjects include religion, Tibet, and ethnicity, with the possibility of a ban.
Jasmine is not banned also, it's ridiculous. Why would it even be banned? There is a hundred-years song in my hometown near Shanghai called "jasmine/茉莉花", ask someone from that region, everyone knows it.
some of these are misrepresentations or lack context.
Chinas one child policy was exempt for ethnic minorities and people in rural areas.
Falun Gong and the Dalai Lama are arguably rightfully banned because the political movements they represent are harmful right wing extremist ones, which is often ignored in western media.
The internet bans can easily be circumvented with VPN's, which many chinese citizens do.
The bans on references mainly refer to public comments with large reach. Punishments for e g internet comments are rare.
From the chinese perspective Animal Farm and Chinese Democracy are hostile foreign propaganda. I'm not american but I'm pretty sure america doesn't allow "death to america" chants from Iranian propagandists in their country either.
Cryptocurrency is deservingly banned. It provides zero positive contribution to society and is very bad for the environment.
All in all there's still a lot wrong with all of this but it's not nearly as bad as many people say
Now free of China, these lamas can say anything they want, like how China slaughtered most of them and burned down hundreds of monasteries, et al. In order to prevent this, the Chinese want to ensure that any new recognized incarnations are in their country, under their control (like their fake Panchen Lama), and not stir up any Tibetan uprisings.
From Wikipedia:
On August 3, 2007, China's State Administration for Religious Affairs issued a decree that all the reincarnations of tulkus of Tibetan Buddhism must get government approval, otherwise they are "illegal or invalid". The decree states, "It is an important move to institutionalize management on reincarnation of living Buddhas. The selection of reincarnates must preserve national unity and solidarity of all ethnic groups and the selection process cannot be influenced by any group or individual from outside the country."
Yeah, so, you get it.
Other Buddhist traditions (Zen, Theravada, Pure Land, etc.) rely only on accomplishment and worthiness to elevate people to revered teacher. The Tibetans were utterly isolated until 1949, but now, seeing that system, are coming to realize that it’s a much, much better idea.
just informative texts without ego motivation are a much lighter read. I have learned a lot :)
out of the millions movies made, for something to be awful they really must be terribly unimaginably bad. A movie isnt awful because you find it boring or dont like the plot etc
but rumours are that even in that small territory there are internal struggles. One part want to call it futonia and the other couchia
Though it's not known for sure what behavior of Justin's put him on the bureau's radar, it has been speculated that it might have to do with him posting a selfie from a Japanese shrine that celebrates war criminals who participated in the rape of Nanjing and other atrocities in China and Korea.
Now South Park is completely banned too.
Here's a hint: not liking communists isn't a USA thing; it's a pretty-much-the-whole-civilized-world thing.
That's a new one! But as an American, I'm glad to see it. What's the opposite of a back-handed compliment?
Also, banning crypto-mining is very much ok for me, it may help to make graphics cards a bit more affordable again...
Also Avatar is not banned in 3D which is kind of weird. The reason of that is cuz the CCP thinks that people wouldn't focus on the central theme being too fascinated by the effects.
he creeps me out
Regarding "Animal Farm", I tweaked the clue as the book is sold in China.
A few notes:
1. Though the reference to the Tian'anmen Square Massacre is strictly banned, the mentioning of the square itself is not —the founding of PRC is proclaimed by Mao on Tian'anmen Gate in 1949, and the once-a-decade military parades are still held at the square (last edition was in 2019)
We Chinese are more used to refer to the incident by its DATE (June 4th) instead of its location, as many other events with substantial historical significance also took place at the Square.
2: The works of George Orwell are not banned.
Also jasmine isn;t banned, you could put it as 'cut flower jasmine from Beijing wholesale markets in 2011', I dunno.
I strongly suspect that the view thought Avatar has been banned in China confused the film with the animation Avatar: The Last Airbender, whose sometimes simplified as Avatar. Despite no clear evidence indicating the animation has been banned, its subjects include religion, Tibet, and ethnicity, with the possibility of a ban.
https://archive.ph/LmVYq
Note: I have tweaked the clue somewhat.
I am Chinese.
It's very sad and misleading, typical American bias.
Chinas one child policy was exempt for ethnic minorities and people in rural areas.
Falun Gong and the Dalai Lama are arguably rightfully banned because the political movements they represent are harmful right wing extremist ones, which is often ignored in western media.
The internet bans can easily be circumvented with VPN's, which many chinese citizens do.
The bans on references mainly refer to public comments with large reach. Punishments for e g internet comments are rare.
From the chinese perspective Animal Farm and Chinese Democracy are hostile foreign propaganda. I'm not american but I'm pretty sure america doesn't allow "death to america" chants from Iranian propagandists in their country either.
Cryptocurrency is deservingly banned. It provides zero positive contribution to society and is very bad for the environment.
All in all there's still a lot wrong with all of this but it's not nearly as bad as many people say
but jetpunk is be allowed