Votes
|
Pos.
|
Team(s)
|
Years with Votes
|
Answer
|
221
|
QB
|
Colts, Broncos
|
'00, '03-'06, '08, '09, '12, '13
|
Peyton Manning
|
180
|
QB
|
Patriots, Buccaneers
|
'03, '05, '07, '10, '13-'17, '21
|
Tom Brady
|
164
|
QB
|
Packers
|
'11, '14, '16, '20, '21
|
Aaron Rodgers
|
91
|
QB
|
Chiefs
|
'19, '20, '22
|
Patrick Mahomes II
|
50
|
QB
|
Ravens
|
'18
|
Lamar Jackson
|
48
|
QB
|
Panthers
|
'15
|
Cam Newton
|
44
|
RB
|
Chargers
|
'06
|
LaDainian Tomlinson
|
41.5
|
RB
|
Rams
|
'00, '01
|
Marshall Faulk
|
33.5
|
RB
|
Vikings
|
'08, '12
|
Adrian Peterson
|
27
|
QB
|
Titans
|
'02, '03
|
Steve McNair
|
25
|
QB
|
Falcons
|
'16
|
Matt Ryan
|
24
|
QB
|
Raiders
|
'00, '02
|
Rich Gannon
|
22.5
|
QB
|
Chargers, Saints
|
'06, '09, '18
|
Drew Brees
|
22.5
|
QB
|
Rams, Cardinals
|
'01, '08
|
Kurt Warner
|
22
|
QB
|
Packers, Vikings
|
'01, '02, '07, '09
|
Brett Favre
|
19
|
RB
|
Seahawks
|
'05
|
Shaun Alexander
|
13
|
DE
|
Texans
|
'14
|
J.J. Watt
|
11
|
QB
|
Eagles
|
'00
|
Donovan McNabb
|
8
|
RB
|
Rams
|
'17
|
Todd Gurley II
|
8
|
RB
|
Titans
|
'00
|
Eddie George
|
6
|
QB
|
Raiders
|
'16
|
Derek Carr
|
6
|
RB
|
Cowboys
|
'16
|
Ezekiel Elliott
|
6
|
RB
|
Giants
|
'05
|
Tiki Barber
|
5
|
QB
|
Bills
|
'20, '22
|
Josh Allen
|
5
|
RB
|
Ravens
|
'03
|
Jamal Lewis
|
4
|
QB
|
Chargers
|
'08, '09
|
Philip Rivers
|
4
|
QB
|
Dolphins
|
'08
|
Chad Pennington
|
4
|
RB
|
Falcons
|
'08
|
Michael Turner
|
4
|
RB
|
Chiefs
|
'02, '03
|
Priest Holmes
|
4
|
QB
|
Steelers
|
'01
|
Kordell Stewart
|
3
|
QB
|
Bengals, Cardinals
|
'05, '15
|
Carson Palmer
|
3
|
OLB
|
Steelers
|
'08
|
James Harrison
|
3
|
MLB
|
Ravens
|
'00, '03
|
Ray Lewis
|
2
|
QB
|
Eagles
|
'17
|
Carson Wentz
|
2
|
QB
|
Cowboys
|
'14
|
Tony Romo
|
2
|
RB
|
Cowboys
|
'14
|
DeMarco Murray
|
2
|
QB
|
Falcons
|
'02, '04
|
Michael Vick
|
2
|
MLB
|
Bears
|
'01
|
Brian Urlacher
|
1
|
QB
|
Eagles
|
'22
|
Jalen Hurts
|
1
|
WR
|
Rams
|
'21
|
Cooper Kupp
|
1
|
QB
|
Cowboys
|
'16
|
Dak Prescott
|
1
|
MLB
|
Seahawks
|
'14
|
Bobby Wagner
|
1
|
RB
|
Titans
|
'08
|
Chris Johnson
|
1
|
LB
|
Buccaneers
|
'02
|
Derrick Brooks
|
|