A lot of these are extremely questionable...I could maybe see arguments for Unitas over Manning, Plunkett over Gannon, etc. but you're trying to claim David Carr over Watson or even Schaub? Delhomme over Newton? Come on
Donovan McNabb is better than Cunningham. Cam Newton is better than Jake Delhomme. Boomer Esiason would be defeated by Ken Anderson. Jim Plunkett? No. KEN STABLER. Vinny Testaverde and not Brad Johnson is also frustrating. Watson or Schaub, both are miles better than David Carr. And Charley Trippi? Well, I guess there's no better QB for the CRADINALS.