#
|
Team(s)
|
Years
|
Player
|
4
|
Boston
|
2001, 2002, 2007, 2008
|
Jason Varitek
|
3
|
Chicago White Stockings
|
1880, 1882, 1885
|
Sliver Flint
|
3
|
Philadelphia, Chicago (AL)
|
1898, 1902, 1905
|
Ed McFarland
|
3
|
Boston
|
1904, 1905, 1908
|
Lou Criger
|
3
|
Chicago (AL)
|
1914, 1917, 1922
|
Ray Schalk
|
3
|
Boston
|
1916, 1917
|
Pinch Thomas
|
3
|
Washington, Boston
|
1916, 1920, 1923
|
Val Picinich
|
3
|
Cleveland, Chicago (AL)
|
1931, 1935, 1937
|
Luke Sewell
|
3
|
Cleveland
|
1947, 1948, 1951
|
Jim Hegan
|
3
|
NY Yankees
|
1951, 1956
|
Yogi Berra
|
3
|
Brooklyn Dodgers
|
1952, 1956
|
Roy Campanella
|
3
|
Milwaukee Braves
|
1954, 1960
|
Del Crandall
|
3
|
LA Dodgers, California
|
1965, 1970, 1973
|
Jeff Torborg
|
3
|
Houston
|
1979, 1981, 1986
|
Alan Ashby
|
3
|
Florida
|
1996, 1997, 2001
|
Charles Johnson
|
2
|
Columbus Buckeyes
|
1884
|
Rudy Kemmler
|
2
|
Chicago White Stockings
|
1880, 1884
|
King Kelly
|
2
|
Brooklyn
|
1886, 1888
|
Jimmy Peoples
|
2
|
Philadelphia, Boston
|
1885, 1892
|
Charlie Ganzel
|
2
|
Philadelphia, Baltimore
|
1888, 1893
|
Wilbert Robinson
|
2
|
Cleveland, Philadelphia
|
1897, 1903
|
Chief Zimmer
|
2
|
Cincinnati
|
1898, 1900
|
Heinie Peitz
|
2
|
Cleveland Naps
|
1908, 1910
|
Nig Clarke
|
2
|
NY Giants, Chicago (FL)
|
1912, 1915
|
Art Wilson
|
2
|
St. Louis Browns
|
1917
|
Hank Severeid
|
2
|
Cincinnati
|
1938
|
Ernie Lombardi
|
2
|
St. Louis, Boston
|
1941, 1950
|
Walker Cooper
|
2
|
Philadelphia A's
|
1945, 1947
|
Buddy Rosar
|
|
#
|
Team(s)
|
Years
|
Player
|
2
|
Boston
|
1962, 1965
|
Bob Tillman
|
2
|
LA Dodgers
|
1962, 1963
|
Johnny Roseboro
|
2
|
Boston, Oakland
|
1962, 1968
|
Jim Pagliaroni
|
2
|
Houston, Montreal
|
1963, 1969
|
John Bateman
|
2
|
Baltimore, Philadelphia
|
1958, 1964
|
Gus Traindos
|
2
|
Cincinnati, St. Louis
|
1965, 1968
|
Johnny Edwards
|
2
|
Cleveland, California
|
1966, 1970
|
Joe Azcue
|
2
|
Philadelphia, Montreal
|
1971, 1972
|
Tim McCarver
|
2
|
Chicago (NL)
|
1972
|
Randy Hundley
|
2
|
Kansas City
|
1973, 1974
|
Fran Healy
|
2
|
Oakland
|
1970, 1975
|
Gene Tenace
|
2
|
Oakland, Cleveland
|
1975, 1977
|
Ray Fosse
|
2
|
Kansas City, St. Louis
|
1977, 1983
|
Darrell Porter
|
2
|
St. Louis
|
1971, 1978
|
Ted Simmons
|
2
|
Cleveland, Montreal
|
1981, 1991
|
Ron Hassey
|
2
|
Detroit, California
|
1984, 1990
|
Lance Parrish
|
2
|
Chicago (AL)
|
1986, 1991
|
Ron Karkovice
|
2
|
LA Dodgers
|
1990, 1992
|
Mike Scioscia
|
2
|
Oakland, Minnesota
|
1990, 1999
|
Terry Steinbach
|
2
|
LA Dodgers
|
1995, 1996
|
Mike Piazza
|
2
|
NY Yankees
|
1996, 1999
|
Joe Girardi
|
2
|
Texas, Detroit
|
1994, 2007
|
Ivan Rodriguez
|
2
|
Florida, Colorado
|
2006, 2010
|
Miguel Olivo
|
2
|
Chicago (AL)
|
2007, 2012
|
A.J. Pierzynski
|
2
|
Philadelphia
|
2010
|
Carlos Ruiz
|
2
|
Cincinnati
|
2012, 2013
|
Ryan Hanigan
|
2
|
San Francisco
|
2012, 2013
|
Buster Posey
|
|