Name the city that is at the exact center of each circle you see on the map!
If you want to know how they were chosen: put a circle of radius 15 at the location of the world's largest city. Now put one for the next largest city that doesn't touch the circle you already placed. Keep going, making sure no previously placed circle is touched!
Data for 1M cities from citypopulation.de, data for smaller cities from geonames.org
Answers are sorted alphabetically
Cities with no more than 10,000 inhabitants are only considered if they have no larger city within 100 km
Another amazing quiz!!! Questions for you: Should Murmansk (pop 307,000) be here? If you mean Georgetown in Guyana, that dot does not cover Georgetown. Should Brasilia be here? Finally, you mentioned that you prefer to use Faa'a in Tahiti rather than Papeete, but can I suggest Papeete be allowed as a type-in?
thanks again for your comments! Murmansk and Brasilia can't appear because they are in 'open' space but their circles would touch other ones (eg Murmansk would touch Archangel). I have added Papeete as a type-in in general (ie in the excel file I use to create quizzes) but had forgotten to add it to this quiz. The Georgetown in this quiz is the capital of Ascension island in the middle of the Atlantic Thanks again!
Also, what is the dot on the coast in central-north Australia? I tried Darwin but it didn't work, and Darwin is the biggest city for a large area in the centre-north of Australia.
that's Palmerston. I can read the answers by moving the mouse over the dot when the quiz is over, but as in previous cases I guess this doesn't work for you? Palmerston's circle almost touches Ambon's so I guess Darwin would overlap it hence it gets excluded. By the way I am now trying to prepare quizzes where you have to type the largest city within the circle which is more intuitive, so thanks for all your comments!
ah, ok, didn't know that! well this time it's slightly different: I guess Palmerston's circle doesn't touch any other circle but Darwin does... I guess there may be more cases like this since I mixed urban data from citypopulation with data from geonames.org which doesn't 'agglomerate'. thanks for your comment!
Brilliant! It's a pity you have to zoom in on each circle to see clearly how much area it covers; for example, the lower circle in New Zealand looks like it covers the whole of the South Island. I typed in various spellings of Christchurch, the biggest city, before trying Dunedin (my home city!), not understanding why that was the correct answer. Then I realized after a few minutes that zooming in on each circle revealed a much smaller area. Any way to fix this?
I also found the instructions confusing. You make it sound like the quiz has to be completed in a specific order, from the largest city on the map all the way down to the smallest. Wouldn't it be simpler to just say "Name the largest city within each circle shown on the map"? Or am I not understanding something? Sorry to sound so critical - this is an amazing concept!
thanks for your comment! sorry for confusing instructions, that's often the case with me!
I'll try explaining in a different way: the circles were added in a specific order: circle around Guangzhou as it's the biggest city, then 2nd biggest etc as long as the circle you add doesn't overlap any circle that's been added already. So you are not looking for the largest city inside a circle but for the one that is at the very center of the circle. This can lead to odd situations like the ones Jerry pointed out: Darwin can't be added because it would touch a circle but Palmerston, only a few km away, can! I could have made the circle with twice the radius as that would highlight the area where you can't have new cities, but then there would have been lots of overlapping. I thought that leaving the circle as 'zoomable' would be helpful in pinpointing where the city you are looking for is. Anyway, after reading Jerry's comments I prepared a quiz where you guess largest cities in circle!
Ok, I think I understand what you mean about the overlapping. :) But couldn't the instructions then just read "Name the city that is at the exact center of each circle you see on the map"? I think all your instructions about 'radius 15' and 'not touching the circles' or 'overlapping' is unnecessary and makes the quiz seem much more complicated than it actually is. Also, without the 'yellow box' requirement, the answers can be completed in any order, so why Guangzhou first?
ok thanks - I guess I wanted to explain how the cities were chosen but then ended up creating more confusion. Eg 'Guangzhou first' refers to how the cities are chosen. thanks again!
Ah, now I understand! You were describing the process by which you created the quiz. It seemed like they were the instructions for the quiz taker. All is clear now :)
I also found the instructions confusing. You make it sound like the quiz has to be completed in a specific order, from the largest city on the map all the way down to the smallest. Wouldn't it be simpler to just say "Name the largest city within each circle shown on the map"? Or am I not understanding something? Sorry to sound so critical - this is an amazing concept!
I'll try explaining in a different way: the circles were added in a specific order: circle around Guangzhou as it's the biggest city, then 2nd biggest etc as long as the circle you add doesn't overlap any circle that's been added already. So you are not looking for the largest city inside a circle but for the one that is at the very center of the circle. This can lead to odd situations like the ones Jerry pointed out: Darwin can't be added because it would touch a circle but Palmerston, only a few km away, can! I could have made the circle with twice the radius as that would highlight the area where you can't have new cities, but then there would have been lots of overlapping. I thought that leaving the circle as 'zoomable' would be helpful in pinpointing where the city you are looking for is. Anyway, after reading Jerry's comments I prepared a quiz where you guess largest cities in circle!