Greatest MLB Lineups Possible

Name the players who'd be a part of the greatest possible lineup for each team.

LIST MADE BY BLEACHER REPORT

Quiz by

Rate:

Last updated: December 1, 2023

You have not attempted this quiz yet.

More quiz info >>

First submitted	October 28, 2019
Times taken	817
Average score	44.4%
Report this quiz	Report

Quiz and answer stats >>

Friends stats >>

40:00

Enter answer here

/ 270 guessed

The quiz is paused. You have remaining.

Scoring
You scored / = %

      This beats or equals
      % of test takers
      also scored 100%
      
The average score is 

        Your high score is
        
      
Your fastest time is 
more stats >>
friends stats >>

Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...

Teams	Pos	Players
Arizona Diamondbacks	SP	Randy Johnson
	C	Miguel Montero
	1B	Paul Goldschmidt
	2B	Jay Bell
	SS	Stephen Drew
	3B	Matt Williams
	LF	Luis Gonzalez
	CF	Steve Finley
	RF	Justin Upton
Atlanta Braves	SP	Warren Spahn
	C	Joe Torre
	1B	Freddie Freeman
	2B	Mark Lemke
	SS	Chipper Jones
	3B	Eddie Mathews
	LF	Dale Murphy
	CF	Andruw Jones
	RF	Hank Aaron
Baltimore Orioles	SP	Jim Palmer
	C	Chris Holies
	1B	Eddie Murray
	2B	Roberto Alomar
	SS	Cal Ripken Jr.
	3B	Brooks Robinson
	LF	Frank Robinson
	CF	Adam Jones
	RF	Nick Markakis
Boston Red Sox	SP	Pedro Martinez
	C	Carlton Fisk
	1B	David Ortiz
	2B	Dustin Pedroia
	SS	Nomar Garciaparra
	3B	Wade Boggs
	LF	Ted Williams
	CF	Manny Ramirez
	RF	Carl Yastrzemski
Chicago White Sox	SP	Ed Walsh
	C	Carlton Fisk
	1B	Frank Thomas
	2B	Eddie Collins
	SS	Luke Appling
	3B	Robin Ventura
	LF	Minnie Minoso
	CF	Shoeless Joe Jackson
	RF	Harold Baines
Chicago Cubs	SP	Fregie Jenkins
	C	Charles Hartnett
	1B	Cap Anson
	2B	Ryne Sandberg
	SS	Ernie Banks
	3B	Ron Santo
	LF	Billy Williams
	CF	Hack Wilson
	RF	Sammy Sosa
Cincinnati Reds	SP	Tom Seaver
	C	Johnny Bench
	1B	Joey Votto
	2B	Joe Morgan
	SS	Barry Larkin
	3B	Tony Perez
	LF	Pete Rose
	CF	Ken Griffey Jr.
	RF	Frank Robinson
Cleveland Indians	SP	Bob Feller
	C	Sandy Alomar Jr.
	1B	Jim Thome
	2B	Napoleon Lajoie
	SS	Lou Boudreau
	3B	Jose Ramirez
	LF	Larry Doby
	CF	Tris Speaker
	RF	Joe Jackson
Colorado Rockies	SP	Ubaldo Jimenez
	C	Chris Iannetta
	1B	Todd Helton
	2B	DJ LeMahieu
	SS	Troy Tulowitzki
	3B	Nolan Arenado
	LF	Matt Holiday
	CF	Dante Bichette
	RF	Larry Walker
Detroit Tigers	SP	Hal Newhouser
	C	Mickey Cochrane
	1B	Hank Greenberg
	2B	Charlie Gehringer
	SS	Alan Trammell
	3B	Miguel Cabrera
	LF	Sam Crawford
	CF	Ty Cobb
	RF	Al Kaline
Houston Astros	SP	Nolan Ryan
	C	Brad Ausmus
	1B	Jeff Bagwell
	2B	Craig Biggio
	SS	Jose Altuve
	3B	Ken Caminiti
	LF	Lance Berkman
	CF	Cesar Cedeno
	RF	Jose Cruz
Kansas City Royals	SP	Bret Saberhagen
	C	Salvador Perez
	1B	Mike Sweeney
	2B	Frank White
	SS	Freddie Patek
	3B	George Brett
	LF	Willie Wilson
	CF	Amos Ottis
	RF	Carlos Beltran
Los Angeles Angels	SP	Nolan Ryan
	C	Bob Boone
	1B	Troy Glaus
	2B	Rod Carew
	SS	Jim Fregoi
	3B	Doug DeClinces
	LF	Tim Salmon
	CF	Mike Trout
	RF	Vladimir Guerrero
Los Angeles Dodgers	SP	Sandy Koufax
	C	Roy Campanella
	1B	Mike Piazza
	2B	Jackie Robinson
	SS	Pee Wee Reese
	3B	Maury Wills
	LF	Zack Wheat
	CF	Duke Snider
	RF	Kirk Gibson
Miami/Florida Marlins	SP	Jose Fernandez
	C	Charles Johnson
	1B	Miguel Cabrera
	2B	Luis Castillo
	SS	Hanley Ramirez
	3B	Mike Lowell
	LF	Cliff Floyd
	CF	Gary Sheffield
	RF	Giancarlo Stanton

Teams	Pos	Players
Milwaukee Brewers	SP	Teddy Higuera
	C	Ted Simmons
	1B	Cecil Cooper
	2B	Paul Molitor
	SS	Robin Yount
	3B	Jeff Cirillo
	LF	Ryan Braun
	CF	Christian Yelich
	RF	Sixto Lezcano
Minnesota Twins	SP	Bert Blyleven
	C	Joe Mauer
	1B	Justin Morneau
	2B	Rod Carew
	SS	Greg Gagne
	3B	Harmon Killebrew
	LF	Kirby Puckett
	CF	Tony Oliva
	RF	Torii Hunter
New York Yankees	SP	Whitey Ford
	C	Yogi Berra
	1B	Lou Gehrig
	2B	Willie Randolph
	SS	Derek Jeter
	3B	Alex Rodriguez
	LF	Joe DiMaggio
	CF	Mickey Mantle
	RF	Babe Ruth
New York Mets	SP	Tom Seaver
	C	Mike Piazza
	1B	Keith Hernandez
	2B	Edgardo Alfonzo
	SS	Jose Reyes
	3B	David Wright
	LF	Carlos Beltran
	CF	Howard Johnson
	RF	Darryl Strawberry
Oakland Athletics	SP	Catfish Hunter
	C	Jimmie Foxx
	1B	Mark Mcgwire
	2B	Eddie Collins
	SS	Bert Campaneris
	3B	Sal Bando
	LF	Dave Henderson
	CF	Rickey Henderson
	RF	Reggie Jackson
Philadelphia Phillies	SP	Steve Carlton
	C	Mike Lieberthal
	1B	Ryan Howard
	2B	Chase Utley
	SS	Jimmy Rollins
	3B	Mike Schmidt
	LF	Greg Luzinski
	CF	Richie Ashburn
	RF	Bryce Harper
Pittsburgh Pirates	SP	Babe Adams
	C	Jason Kendall
	1B	Willie Stargell
	2B	Bill Mazeroski
	SS	Honus Wagner
	3B	Pie Traynor
	LF	Dave Parker
	CF	Roberto Clemente
	RF	Ralph Kiner
San Diego Padres	SP	Randy Jones
	C	Benito Santiago
	1B	Adrian Gonzalez
	2B	Mark Loretta
	SS	Fernando Tatis Jr.
	3B	Ken Caminiti
	LF	Phil Nevin
	CF	Dave Winfield
	RF	Tony Gwynn
San Francisco Giants	SP	Christy Mathewson
	C	Buster Posey
	1B	Willie McCovey
	2B	Jeff Kent
	SS	George Davis
	3B	Matt Williams
	LF	Barry Bonds
	CF	Willie Mays
	RF	Mel Ott
Seattle Mariners	SP	Randy Johnson
	C	Dan Wilson
	1B	Alvin Davis
	2B	Harold Reynolds
	SS	Alex Rodriguez
	3B	Edgar Martinez
	LF	Jay Buhner
	CF	Ken Griffey Jr.
	RF	Ichiro Suzuki
St. Louis Cardinals	SP	Bob Gibson
	C	Yadier Molina
	1B	Mark McGwire
	2B	Roger Hornsby
	SS	Ozzie Smith
	3B	Albert Pujols
	LF	Lou Brock
	CF	Stan Musial
	RF	Enos Slaughter
Tampa Bay Rays	SP	David Price
	C	Toby Hall
	1B	Fred McGriff
	2B	Ben Zobrist
	SS	Julio Lugo
	3B	Evan Longoria
	LF	Carl Crawford
	CF	Melvin Upton
	RF	Matt Joyce
Texas Rangers	SP	Nolan Ryan
	C	Ivan Rodriguez
	1B	Rafael Palmeiro
	2B	Ian Kinsler
	SS	Michael Young
	3B	Adrian Beltre
	LF	Nelson Cruz
	CF	Josh Hamilton
	RF	Juan Gonzalez
Toronto Blue Jays	SP	Roy Halladay
	C	Ernie Whitt
	1B	Carlos Delgado
	2B	Roberto Alomar
	SS	Tony Fernandez
	3B	Josh Donaldson
	LF	George Bell
	CF	Joe Carter
	RF	Jose Bautista
Washington Nationals/Expos/Senators	SP	Walter Johnson
	C	Gary Carter
	1B	Andres Galarraga
	2B	Jose Vidro
	SS	Trea Turner
	3B	Ryan Zimmerman
	LF	Tim Raines
	CF	Andre Dawson
	RF	Vladimir Guerrero