Year
|
Team
|
Clue
|
Player
|
2016
|
MIA
|
British born RB who shocked the NFL by recording 1,272 rush yards and becoming just the third player to record three 200+ yard games in a season, only to fail to surpass this yardage total in his next three seasons combined
|
Jay Ajayi
|
2015
|
CLE
|
TE who caught 79 passes for 1,043 yards in his 7th season in the NFL, more than his total yardage in the previous six seasons combined
|
Gary Barnidge
|
2012
|
NWE
|
RB who rushed for 1,263 yards and 12 touchdowns, helping the Patriots to the AFC championship game, before 4 lost fumbles in the 2013 season earned him a spot on the bench, where he stayed for the remainder of his career
|
Stevan Ridley
|
2012
|
CLE
|
RB taken third overall in the draft, who opened his career with a solid 950 rushing yards and 11 TDs, followed by two abysmal seasons for the Indianapolis Colts, after which he never played another NFL snap
|
Trent Richardson
|
2011
|
DEN
|
QB who led the Broncos to an 8-8 record and wildcard playoff berth after a 1-4 start, followed by a miraculous playoff victory against the previous Super Bowl Runner-Up Pittsburgh Steelers, who then only lasted one more year in the league
|
Tim Tebow
|
2010
|
CLE
|
RB who rushed for 1,177 yards whilst also making 61 receptions to set the fantasy football world alight, culminating in him winning the first ever Madden cover poll. He's now renowned for suffering from the 'Madden Curse'
|
Peyton Hillis
|
2008
|
HOU
|
Rookie RB who recorded 1,282 yards and 9 TD in his debut season, then only added another 614 yards in his next three seasons combined before he was out of the league
|
Steve Slaton
|
2007
|
NYG
|
Special teams WR who shot to superstardom after his iconic 'Helmet Catch' in Super Bowl XLII, who then never recorded another catch in the NFL
|
David Tyree
|
2004
|
TAM
|
WR who recorded 1,193 yards and 7 TDs in his rookie year, he only added 3 more TDs to this total until his retirement in 2011
|
Michael Clayton
|
1999
|
CHI
|
WR who broke out in his sophomore year to record 1,400 receiving yards and 9 TDs, he never surpassed 750 yards in any of his remaining 7 NFL seasons
|
Marcus Robinson
|
1998
|
NWE
|
Rookie RB who rushed for 1,115 yards and 9 TDs before suffering a horror knee injury during a flag football game that almost required amputation. He only recorded 107 more NFL rushing yards before dropping to the CFL
|
Robert Edwards
|
1995
|
DAL
|
CB who recorded a career high 6 INTs on the season, then became the first CB to win Super Bowl MVP after his two INTs against the Steelers, who only played 12 more games after his breakout year
|
Larry Brown
|
1995
|
CHI
|
Heisman winning rookie RB who became the youngest player to reach 1,000 rushing yards, he sadly only lasted 2 more years in the NFL, before tragically taking his own life in 2016
|
Rashaan Salaam
|
1989
|
GNB
|
QB who broke out with 4,319 passing yards and 27 TDs, and beat the rival Chicago Bears for the first time since 1984. He never recorded more than 10 passing TDs in any of his 9 other NFL seasons
|
Don Majkowski
|
1988
|
CIN
|
FB who recorded 1,066 rushing yards and 15 touchdowns in his rookie year, and started a dance craze with his iconic touchdown celebration, before a torn ACL hampered the rest of his career
|
Ickey Woods
|