Me too...where else can you go and hear nerds bitch about the difference between city and urban area population. Grab some popcorn...it's gonna be good.
There is absolutely no way that Washington DC is the fourth-biggest city in the country. It isn't even close. Might not be in top 20, and certainly not in the top ten. Houston is the fourth-biggest city. Dallas, Phoenix, San Jose, and San Diego are all much, much bigger cities, just to name a few.
Metro areas are weird. New York, Washington, and Atlanta have utterly ridiculous bounds, for example, and Guangzhou envelopes several other major cities to technically call itself the largest in the world. But municipal limits are possibly even weirder. Alexandria and Arlington are two small cities outside Washington, D.C., and any reasonable person would call them suburbs (Alexandria's biggest attraction is a smallish house). But they're not encompassed in the city limits. I'd say in Washington's case the metro area is the lesser of two evils, but it's ambiguous, and should really be worked out at some point.
^^ As with any American city. Suburbanites fight tooth and nail to stay municipally separate and not to pay taxes to the central city that's the only reason the metro area exists, use the city's infrastucture heavily, but always tell people they're from City Name. Hypocrites.
IsleAuHaulte ... we say we're from 'city name' because nobody would know what we were talking about if we said the actual name of the suburb; no infrastructure in said city benefits us in the slightest and we have no responsibility to pay for it. We are different in that we live in a different state, we have lawns and they don't. They have a weird accent and we don't. We're different but still go by NYC because Americans don't know where Stamford is.
-Someone living in a town bordering Stamford, CT, which is itself usually classified as a part of the NYC metro
jemellor13, Houston is fourth in city population, but this quiz is asking for urban area population, which is something totally different. As an example, cities like Jacksonville, Columbus and Indianapolis have large city populations because their city limits are all-encompassing of most suburban areas. Cities like Washington and Boston, however, have small city limits without suburban areas, but their metro population is extraordinarily large.
I live in a Washington suburb, and the population of the District of Columbia itself is quite small. However, most of the quizzes combine it with Baltimore and everything in between as well as Virginia suburbs like Alexandria and Arlington, which together are something like 60% or more of DC.
Trust those of us who live here, please. We who live in Northern Virginia and Southern Maryland are part of the DC Metro area despite being in different states. And the population density is insane.
According to a cursory internet search DC metro area has 1200/ sq mile and the central DC has 11000/sq mile. While high it is by no means highest in the world. Here is a list of cities which are at least 4 times denser: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_population_density
Katerina is a form of Katherine, and Catherine the Great went to Russia, so I think of it as Ye Katerina Burg. Unfortunately, one has to remember the city before one can remember the spelling and I did neither this time around.
Someone in the renaming department in Kolkata had a sense of humour when they were renaming streets in that city. They renamed the street that the US consulate is on Ho Chi Minh Street...
Everyone saying that this city is bigger than this city and whatever...Quizmaster lists his source. If you think something is wrong, perhaps contact the original source? I'm sure QM isn't going to change an answer based upon the "say so" of a user.
Sort of. Those things are usually defined consistently within countries, but are often defined wildly differently between them. I still can't get over Okayama, Japan apparently being the heart of a metro area of over 2 million.
Actually, they don't "sometimes" include the suburbs in Northern Virginia and Southern Maryland, they all the time include them. We are absolutely part of the Metro DC urban area, both officially and in practicality.
If they're going by metro or urban area they group in portions of Virginia and Maryland. But those portions vary in size and affect how they calculate the total population, and if they're going by city proper they're not included at all. Sometimes is accurate.
Fun quiz. Though it's annoying how people are always correcting these population quizzes as if they're the unquestioned lord and master of census taking
It's pretty amazing how Houston, Dallas, and Miami can all be the 4th biggest city in the USA. All these people trying to correct the quiz can't even agree on which city is right (hint: it's probably the city in the quiz!)
It's amazing that only 4% of quiz takers know about Xiamen. I didn't. A city of 3.5 million Xiameners going about their Xiamener business day in and day out, year after year and I had no idea that they even existed. I need to travel more broadly, I think.
I got 55 which I was pretty proud of. And whilst people are disputing what city is bigger than what in other countries, the top 5 in Australia are most definitely correct. Actually, these 5 cities account for 63.5% of the entire population of the country. Maybe someone could do a quiz on countries with highest rates of urbanization or population concentration or whatever it may be called. And another for the opposite, most diverse or spread out, scattered like lost fragments, spread like lost souls cast on the wind, or something like that.
Urban area or not, DC and San Fran should not be in top 5. It should be NY, LA, Chicago, Dallas and Houston if you go by Metropolitan Statistical Area. It should be NY, LA, Chicago, Houston and Philly by city limits.
What a great ideia for a quiz! If you're thinking about a second edition I think a good list of countries would be Argentina, Pakistan, Indonesia, South Korea, Vietnam, Philippines, Nigeria, D. R. Congo, Italy, France, Germany, Spain.
Maybe some day a quiz maker will issue a series titled "For This Quiz We're Looking for URBAN AREAS. Understand??? Not CITIES - URBAN AREAS (slap-slap-slap) UUUUURBAN AAAAAREEEEAAAAS".
Just come across this quiz. United Kingdom list is very wrong. All the cities are in England. Glasgow, at just over 800k is the third largest city in the UK. Bristol at 617k is larger than either Liverpool 540k or Manchester 520k.
Did you read the caveats or any comments above? If you did, you should say, “maybe use a different way of measuring population,” instead of insisting one thing like a arrogant idiot. It’s been stated a lot how the population is measured on this quiz, so deal with it. They are both correct, so QM has to choose which one he wants.
I live in Xiamen. It's not even the biggest city in this province, let alone 5th in all, of China. Xiamen only has around 5 million people: Chngqing, by comparison, has more than 30 million people!
Ecatepec is bigger than Toluca https://www.bing.com/search?q=ecatepec+population&form=EDGEAR&qs=PF&cvid=f5e7e69ad9184e04b37911a86d045100&cc=GB&setlang=en-US&PC=LCTS and https://www.bing.com/search?q=toluca+population&form=EDGEAR&qs=TPP&cvid=86b6c80fa1c049768f0c6c4cafeb8f43&cc=GB&setlang=en-US&PC=LCTS
Looking on Google maps, it appears that Ecatapec is in the same urban area as Mexico city appearing in a gray area contiguous with Mexico city and thus could be considered part of Mexico city.
Pretty happy with 55/60 and getting Puebla, Toluca, and Bucaramanga. Missed Monterrey, Sapporo, Tianjin, Nizhny Novgorod and Fukuoka, definitely could have gotten most of those.
-Someone living in a town bordering Stamford, CT, which is itself usually classified as a part of the NYC metro
http://www.citypopulation.de/world/Agglomerations.html
To quote GOB, "C'mon!"
urban connections between cities(I.e. rail connections/bus routes/subways)
while the csa has a looser requirement. DFW is the 4th msa and Washington
is 4th in csa.
Cheers!
Only missed Sapporo in Japan and Tianjin in China.
But only managed to get Moscow and St Petersburg in Russia and only Bogota for Colombia.
Good quiz, a mix of well known and obscure countries (well, cities). Would love to see more editions of this quiz!
https://www.census.gov/data/datasets/2016/demo/popest/total-metro-and-micro-statistical-areas.html
Then follow it up with cities.
Bogota: capital city, among the highest capitals in the world. Almost every colombian hates her, but almost everyone lives here
Medellín: second biggest city, used to have a big cartel. Only one in Colombia with "metro" rapid transit
Cali: Salsa big bands, biggest city near the Pacific, used to have the other big cartel
Barranquilla: biggest city in the colombian caribean coast. Some very beautiful mixed latino/lebanese girls
Bucaramanga: Only city in the world where women iron with their own bare hands.
City population of: Glasgow = 635k vs Liverpool = 864k
Urban population of: Glasgow = 1.68M vs Liverpool = 1.5M
Be sure to check it out!!
Top Five Biggest Cities In Asia
Thinking of a Risk board was completely useless for Russia.
I only got them all for Britain, India, Australia, Canada and South Africa. That's the Commonwealth outlook for you I suppose
I spelled Yekaterinburg wrong );
I don't think so.
Great Quiz!