thumbnail

Each MLB Team's Best Non-HOFers

For each Major League Baseball team, name one of the five top players by Baseball-Reference WAR who isn't in the Hall of Fame.
Players must have started their career after 1920, and not be active or still eligible for the Hall of Fame.
Quiz by mroc137
Rate:
Last updated: January 27, 2021
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedSeptember 12, 2020
Times taken22
Average score43.3%
Report this quizReport
8:00
Enter answer here
0
 / 30 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
Team
Answer
A's
Sal Bando | Bert Campaneris | Bob Johnson | Mark McGwire | Barry Zito
Angels
Chuck Finley | Jim Fregosi | Tim Salmon | Brian Downing | Bobby Grich
Astros
Jose Cruz | Cesar Cedeno | Lance Berkman | Roy Oswalt | Jim Wynn
Blue Jays
Dave Stieb | Tony Fernandez | Carlos Delgado | Jimmy Key | Jesse Barfield
Braves
Dale Murphy | Wally Berger | Tommy Holmes | Johnny Logan | Joe Torre
Brewers
Cecil Cooper | Teddy Higuera | Don Money | Jeff Cirillo | Ben Sheets
Cardinals
Ken Boyer | Curt Flood | Harry Brecheen | Jim Edmonds | Ray Lankford
Cubs
Stan Hack | Rick Reuschel | Mark Grace | Carlos Zambrano | Bill Nicholson
Diamondbacks
Brandon Webb | Luis Gonzalez | Steve Finley | Dan Haren | Miguel Batista
Dodgers
Willie Davis | Ron Cey | Orel Hershiser | Gil Hodges | Jim Gillam
Giants
Bobby Bonds | Will Clark | Johnny Antonelli | Jim Barr | Robby Thompson
Indians
Kenny Lofton | Mel Harder | Sam McDowell | Wes Ferrell | Ken Keltner
Mariners
Jamie Moyer | Jay Buhner | Alvin Davis | Bret Boone | Mark Langston
Marlins
Josh Johnson | Luis Castillo | Dontrelle Willis | Cliff Floyd | Dan Uggla
Mets
Dwight Gooden | Jerry Koosman | Darryl Strawberry | Edgardo Alfonzo | Sid Fernandez
Nationals/Expos
Steve Rogers | Tim Wallach | Dennis Martinez | Marquis Grissom | Javier Vasquez
Orioles
Mark Belanger | Paul Blair | Bobby Grich | Boog Powell | Brady Anderson
Padres
Andy Ashby | Andy Benes | Gene Tenace | Randy Jones | Gene Richards
Phillies
Bobby Abreu | Johnny Callison | Dick Allen | Del Ennis | Chris Short
Pirates
Bob Friend | Dave Parker | John Candelaria | Vern Law | Andy Van Slyke
Rangers
Rafael Palmeiro | Buddy Bell | Jim Sundberg | Charlie Hough | Toby Harrah
Rays
Carlos Pena | Julio Lugo | Aubrey Huff | Jason Bartlett | Rocco Baldelli
Red Sox
Dwight Evans | Nomar Garciaparra | Rico Petrocelli | Luis Tiant | Reggie Smith
Reds
Pete Rose | Vada Pinson | Bucky Walters | Dave Concepcion | George Foster
Rockies
Vinny Castilla | Aaron Cook | Andres Galarraga | Ellis Burks | Steve Reed
Royals
Kevin Appier | Amos Otis | Willie Wilson | Bret Saberhagen | Mark Gubicza
Tigers
Lou Whitaker | Norm Cash | Tommy Bridges | Dizzy Trout | Mickey Lolich
Twins/Senators
Brad Radke | Tony Oliva | Buddy Myer | Kent Hrbek | Chuck Knoblauch
White Sox
Wilbur Wood | Billy Pierce | Minnie Minoso | Robin Ventura | Paul Konerko
Yankees
Willie Randolph | Bernie Williams | Ron Guidry | Roy White | Thurman Munson
+1
Level 55
Jan 27, 2021
Updated after the 2021 election: Dan Haren and Barry Zito now make the list.