I thought maybe they were looking for Cap'n Crunch.
Also, wtf? Isn't Nutella German?
Who doesn't know Pirate's Booty.
Best stuff on Earth.
I AM CONFUSION
So it's a matter of what's more likely: genuinely named after someone popular nearly 30 years earlier and dead for 17, or named for one of the most famous athletes in the country at the time (but changed just enough and given just enough of a plausible explanation so they didn't have to pay him anything.)
Never heard of Pirate's Booty.
Remembered Toaster Strudel and got it in with 3 seconds left