Politics: Anarchism - Human Nature

This is a quiz based on how Anarchists view human nature, which is covered in the AQA A-Level Politics Specification: Max Stirner (1806-1856) Peter Kropotkin (1842-1921) Mikhail Bakunin (1814-1876) Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809-1865) Emma Goldman (1869-1940) Social Darwinism Élisée Reclus (1830-1905) Enrico Malatesta (1853-1932) Sergei Nechaev (1847-1882) David Friedman (1945-) Murray Rothbard (1926-1995) William Godwin (1756-1836)
Quiz by billyn
Rate:
Last updated: March 6, 2024
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedJanuary 18, 2024
Times taken2
Report this quizReport
10:00
Enter answer here
0
 / 12 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
Answer
Hint
Sergei Nechaev (1847-1882)
This individualist anarchist and most notorious exponent of egoism, in 'The Revolutionary Catechism' (1869), summed up the idea that the revolutionary can have no morality thus:
-'The revolutionary enters the world of the State, of the privileged classes, of the so-called civilization, and he lives in this world only for the purpose of bringing about its speedy and total destruction. He is not a revolutionary if he has any sympathy for this world. He should not hesitate to destroy any position, any place, or any man in this world. He must hate everyone and everything in it with an equal hatred. All the worse for him if he has any relations with parents, friends, or lovers; he is no longer a revolutionary if he is swayed by these relationships.'.
David Friedman (1945-)
This anarcho-capitalist argued that people are fundamentally economic animals (as opposed to social animals):
-We have an innate sense of entitlement, he argues, meaning that mankind is born with a belief that we are entitled to anything in nature as long as we have worked to gain it.
-To this robust defence of private property, he adds that we must be free to enter economic relations with others - this must be unregulated if it is to be mutually beneficial.
Mikhail Bakunin (1814-1876)
This key thinker argues we are fundamentally social animals and productive work characterises our humanity:
-For him there was no contradiction between an ordered society and individual liberty.
-In his work, 'God and the State' (1871), he wrote: 'The liberty of man consists solely in this, that he obeys the laws of nature because he has himself recognized them as such, and not because they have been imposed upon him externally by any foreign will whatsoever, human or divine, collective or individual.'.
-What he meant by this was that it is natural for people to obey the laws of nature and they do not need to be forced to do so, therefore they retain their freedom.
-The laws of nature include such ideas as the sociability of mankind, natural empathy for each other, equality and respect for each other's freedom.
-For him, the only impulse we have when we are born is towards some kind of natural justice - we do understand the difference between good and evil, but there is nothing that compels us to act in any particular way.
-It depends on our experiences of life whether we follow the rules of natural justice.
-He professed to be a lover of freedom but insisted that the natural state of mankind is to live in communities and to be mutually supportive.
-Indeed, he argued that we are free only if we live in such groups.
-He wrote in 1872, 'To be free means every man living in a social milieu not to surrender his thought or will to any authority, but his own reason and his own understanding of justice.'.
Élisée Reclus (1830-1905)
This French anarchist insisted that whatever kind of social organisation might be adopted, mutual aid will ensure solidarity and progress:
-In 'Evolution and Revolution' (1891), he stated: 'But whether it is a question of small or large groups of the human species, it is always through solidarity, through the association of spontaneous, coordinated forces that all progress is made...they will owe it to their coming together more and more intimately, to incessant collaboration, to this mutual aid from which brotherhood grows little by little.'.
William Godwin (1756-1836)
This political philosopher, who is considered the first modern proponent of anarchism:
-Was an early advocate of the idea that we are capable of moral perfection.
-Argued that if people are allowed to use private judgement, they will not infringe on the freedom of others, so laws are unnecessary.
Peter Kropotkin (1842-1921)
This key thinker argues people are sociable and prefer collective activity:
-In 'Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution', he challenged the beliefs held by Social Darwinists, arguing that in most of the animal world, creatures are cooperative and not competitive.
-Most animals live in natural social groups and engage in mutual aid.
-Thus, he concluded, this was the natural state of mankind too.
-He stated, 'Therefore combine - practise mutual aid! That is the surest means for giving to each and to all the greatest safety, the best guarantee of existence and progress, bodily, intellectual and moral. That is what Nature teaches us; and that is what all those animals which have attained the highest position of their respective classes have done'.
-Also linking with economics, he pleaded, 'Don't compete! Competition is always injurious to the species, and you have plenty of resources to avoid it!'.
-He and his communist colleagues said that mankind is naturally sociable, so people will find freedom within voluntary social groups - 'Are bees in a hive free?', he would ask.
-'Yes' was his answer because they voluntarily and naturally live collectively without any external force.
-His belief in self-sufficiency and equality in small communities made him popular within the commune movement which arose in the 1960s among young, so-called hippies.
-His ideas for promoting self-sufficiency have also endeared him to contemporary 'anarcho-environmentalists' who combine the ideas of communal living with the preservation of scarce resources and opposition to further industrialisation.
-Above all, he is known for his assertion that anarchy represents order and that the kind of utopia he envisaged is capable of becoming a reality.
-He was, perhaps, the most scientific of all anarchist thinkers.
Murray Rothbard (1926-1995)
This anarcho-capitalist, in 'Man, Economy and State' (1962), stated:
-'It's true: greed has had a very bad press. I frankly don't see anything wrong with greed. I think that the people who are always attacking greed would be more consistent with their position if they refused their next salary increase. I don't see even the most Left-Wing scholar in this country scornfully burning his salary check. In other words, "greed" simply means that you are trying to relieve the nature given scarcity that man was born with.'
Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809-1865)
This key thinker argues we are characterised by our productive abilities and creativity as producers:
-His hopes for a reconciliation between individualism and collectivism are summed up in these words, in 'What is Property?, (1840): 'When politics and home life have become one and the same, when economic problems have been solved in such a way that individual and collective interests are identical - all constraints having disappeared - it is evident that we will be in a state of total liberty or anarchy.'.
Max Stirner (1806-1856)
This key thinker argues we are fundamentally self-interested egoists:
-He had the most pessimistic view of human nature in the anarchist movement.
-He argued that the ego - the desire for our own self-realisation even at the expense of others - is the main driving force of the individual's life aspiration.
-He insisted humans are rational creatures who understand our self-interest, but we are also without morality.
-Social morality restrains us and prevents us from being truly liberated - the only way in which people would cooperate with each other would be for selfish reasons - when they saw it as in their self-interest to do so.
-In place of ideology and organised religion, he advocated that each individual should develop their sense of ego.
-In 'The Ego and His Own' (1845), he argued that the individual was entitled to anything they could find in the world.
-Furthermore, it was the right of one's ego to use other people for one's own purposes.
-In reference to the above, he stated, 'Where the world comes in my way - and it comes in my way everywhere - I consume it to quiet the hunger of my egoism. For me you are nothing but my food, even as I too am fed upon and turned to use by you. We have only one relation to each other, that of usableness, of utility, of use'.
-Therefore, he can be seen as a champion of unrestrained individual liberty - not only must the state and private property be abolished to establish the widest possible freedom, he insisted, but so must any moral restraints that might inhibit the individual.
-So, morality, religion, ideology and philosophy are all to be resisted by the free individual.
-However, he did also assert that there was another side to man's nature than mere egoism.
-He claimed that people are capable of altruism, of fellow feeling, but this would show itself only if a person's ego saw altruism as being in their own interests.
-His followers, egoists, developed a reputation for extreme violence and opposing any form of organised society.
Emma Goldman (1869-1940)
This key thinker stresses the need for individual liberty - the desire for freedom is fundamental to mankind:
-She was involved in a number of social causes, not least of which was the emancipation of women and the tolerance of homosexuality, and she championed the idea of free love.
-It is claimed she was the first anarcha-feminist.
-She popularised anarchism's main idea, by connecting its ideal to the emancipation of the individual and the replacement of exploitation by the idea of mutual love.
-Once freed from oppression, she preached to sizeable crowds in the US, the true nature of our loving feeling for each other can be released.
-She raged against virtually every enemy of individual liberty - the modern state, religion, nationalism, Marxism, capitalism, patriarchy and bigotry of any kind.
-In her book, 'Anarchism and Other Essays' (1910), she summed up anarchism thus: 'Anarchism stands for the liberation of the human mind from the dominion of religion and liberation of the human mind from the coercion of property; liberation from the shackles and restraint of government. It stands for a social order based on the free grouping of individuals.'.
Enrico Malatesta (1853-1932)
This Italian anarchist, a close colleague of Kropotkin and Reclus, saw such solidarity and mutual aid as best served by people being grouped together on the basis of their occupation:
-By undertaking similar work, he believed, people would have a greater sense of collective consciousness.
Social Darwinism
This theory flourished in the 1860s and 1870s:
-This theory drew inspiration from the animal kingdom.
-According to Darwin's theories, animals were engaged in a struggle based on the survival of the fittest.
-This promoted competition for scarce food resources, with only those able to adapt to a changing environment able to prevail in this struggle.
-Under capitalism, it was argued, humans were engaged in a similar struggle, in which some would succeed and prosper while others would fail and remain poor.
-Thus, inequality was natural, according to supporters of this theory.
Comments
No comments yet