Fun quiz! I just checked the map and Georgia definitely falls east of Ohio. Wisconsin also doesn’t seem to be farther East than the other choices. You got me checking maps so that’s something!
Believe it or not Ohio actually falls about 0.2 degrees east of Tybee Island, the easternmost point of Georgia. Rock Island off of Wisconsin is also about 1 degree east of the easternmost point in IL and about 2 degrees east of MS.