Hint
|
Answer
|
What categories does this include?
|
Dementia, Schizophrenia, Affective disorders and Personality disorders
|
What approach does the ICD have?
|
A criterion-based approach
|
Strengths of Diagnosis
|
DSM is high in reliability (Brown, 2002), high inter-rater reliability (Pederson,2001), ICD is objective (criterion approach), Good predictive validity (Mason et al, 1997)
|
What did Brown (2002) do?
|
Tested the reliability and validity of the DSM IV for anxiety and mood disorders and found it good to excellent
|
What did Pederson (2001) find?
|
Found that 71% of psychiatrists agreed with the ICD 10 definition of depression when assessing 116 patients.
|
What did Mason et al (1997) find?
|
The ICD was reasonably good at predicting disability 13 years later. Therefore good predictive validity
|
Factors that impact reliability of Diagnosis
|
Patient Factors and Clinician Factors
|
What are patient factors?
|
When patients give psychiatrists slightly different information. Could lead to differing diagnosis
|
What are clinician factors?
|
When the clinicians using the classification systems aren't completely objective
|
Weaknesses of Diagnosis
|
Early versions had poor diagnostic reliability (Spitzer and Williams, 1985) (Hiller et al (1992), subject to clinician factors and patient factors
|
What did Spitzer and Williams (1985) do?
|
Reviewed the process of Diagnosis and found that experienced psychiatrists agree 50% of the time
|
What did Hiller et al (1992) find?
|
Reliability is in doubt for some disorders related to Schizophrenia
|
Issues with the classification system
|
Could be bias (Cochrane et al, 1995), Can't apply cross-culturally (Littlewood, 1992)
|
What did Cochrane et al (1995) argue?
|
Classification systems themselves lead practitioners to take a Eurocentric bias (based on European ideas)
|
What did Littlewood (1992) find?
|
The DSM IV makes assumptions about nuclear family life that aren't applicable cross-culturally
|
What is the Clinical Psychology Classic Study?
|
Rosenhan (1973)
|
What is concurrent validity?
|
If two pieces of evidence agree
|
What is aetiological validity?
|
When the cause is understood
|
What is predictive validity?
|
When the future course of the disorder is known
|